Wrestler Name	Date Won	Location	Defeated	Length of Reign
Jackie Baccaro	07.10.03	New York, NY	Greg Price^1	84 days
Greg Price	10.02.03	Elmhurst, NY	Kris Anthony^2	56 days
Kris Anthony	11.27.03	Hempstead, NY	Greg Price	124 days
Damien Fields	03.30.04	Minneapolis, MN	Kris Anthony	92 days
Martin Blackburn	07.01.04	Jersey City, NJ	Damien Fields	21 days
Mista Jones	07.22.04	Hempstead, NY	Martin Blackburn	54 days

¹ This was a tournament final to crown inaugural tag team champions

² This was a tournament final to crown a new champion after Jackie Baccaro won the NYCW Championship and was forced to vacate this belt

³ After going on hiatus with all championships suspended on September 14, 2004, NYCW and all of its titles were officially declared defunct on March 5, 2005